Revolution808 is built around constructive feedback and iteration. These guidelines exist to protect that culture and make the platform useful for everyone.
They aren’t about restricting creativity — they’re about keeping feedback meaningful, respectful, and focused on improvement.
The core principle
Critique the track, not the person.
Feedback should help the artist make better decisions about their music.
How to give constructive feedback
Good feedback on Revolution808 is:
Specific
Point to a particular moment, sound, or decision.
Instead of:
“The mix feels off”
Try:
“The kick feels buried once the bass comes in at 1:12 — you might try sidechaining or carving space around 60–80Hz.”
Actionable
Feedback should suggest a direction, not just an opinion.
Instead of:
“This doesn’t work”
Try:
“The breakdown might benefit from more contrast — maybe remove the drums entirely for the first 8 bars.”
Honest but respectful
Direct feedback is encouraged. Dismissive or hostile comments are not.
You can say:
“The vocal melody feels weak compared to the instrumental.”
You should not say:
“This is bad” or “You don’t know what you’re doing.”
Aligned with the feedback focus
When an artist tells you what they want feedback on, respond to that first.
If they ask about arrangement, don’t ignore it to comment only on sound design — unless you clearly explain why.
How to receive feedback
If you submit a track, you’re expected to:
- remain open to critique
- understand that feedback is subjective
- decide for yourself what to apply and what to ignore
Not all feedback will be useful. That’s normal.
Responding to feedback — even briefly — helps keep discussions productive and encourages others to engage.
What doesn’t belong here
Revolution808 is not the place for:
- spam or self-promotion without engagement
- finished, already-released tracks
- drive-by comments with no substance
- disrespectful or abusive behaviour
Repeated misuse of the platform may result in removal.
Ownership and respect
You retain full ownership of your music.
Do not re-upload, redistribute, or misuse other members’ work without permission.
A note on disagreement
Disagreement is expected. Healthy debate often leads to better outcomes.
If you disagree with feedback:
- explain your reasoning
- keep the discussion focused on the track
- avoid escalating into personal arguments
Revolution808 works when members treat it as a shared workspace, not a competition.
Listen carefully. Speak honestly. Help each other make better music.