Good feedback is what makes Revolution808 work.
The goal isn’t to judge tracks or show expertise — it’s to help other musicians move unfinished music forward.
Use the principles below to keep feedback useful, focused, and respectful.
1. Listen with intent
Before commenting, take a moment to understand:
- What stage the track is at
- What the creator is trying to achieve
- What they’ve asked for feedback on
If the uploader has specified a focus (mix, structure, sound design, etc.), start there.
2. Be specific, not general
Vague reactions aren’t very helpful.
Instead of:
- “This is cool”
- “Not feeling it”
- “The mix is off”
Try:
- “The low end feels crowded when the bass and kick hit together at 0:45”
- “The breakdown works emotionally, but the energy drop feels a bit long”
- “The lead sound is interesting, but it gets masked once the pads come in”
Specific feedback gives the creator something they can actually work with.
3. Describe what you hear, not what you’d do
Feedback works best when it’s observational, not prescriptive.
Good feedback sounds like:
- “It feels like the vocal gets lost when the chorus opens up”
- “The groove tightens when the hi-hats drop out”
Less helpful:
- “You should use a different synth”
- “I’d change the whole arrangement”
Let the creator decide how to act on what you’re hearing.
4. Separate taste from problems
Personal taste is valid — just label it clearly.
For example:
- “This might be a taste thing, but the distortion feels quite aggressive for the mood”
- “Not my usual genre, but the arrangement is clear and easy to follow”
This helps creators distinguish between objective issues and subjective preference.
5. Balance critique with clarity
You don’t need to soften feedback with praise — but clarity matters.
Helpful comments:
- Focus on a small number of points
- Explain why something isn’t working for you
- Avoid piling on every possible issue at once
Progress comes from iteration, not overwhelm.
6. Respect the work-in-progress
Tracks on Revolution808 are unfinished by design.
That means:
- Rough edges are expected
- Experiments are encouraged
- Early versions are welcome
Feedback should help shape what’s there — not dismiss it for not being “done”.
7. Be the kind of listener you’d want
The simplest rule:
Give the kind of feedback you’d want to receive on your own unfinished track.
Thoughtful feedback builds trust, improves the quality of discussion, and directly affects the feedback you’ll get in return.
One last thing
Revolution808 works best when it’s treated as a shared workspace, not a competition.
Everyone is here to improve — including you.